Most of the GEO advice I see, on getting recommended in AI answers, comes from a tool or template and gives every business the same recommendations before anyone checks what those answers say about it.
What moves the needle is work on your business in particular, starting with what AI answers say about you now, then fixing what matters first and earning what other sites say about you.
I see those shortcuts in the GEO offerings other providers publish and in the skills they advertise on their sites, and in 25+ years in search I’ve seen the same shortcuts sold as SEO. Like automated SEO audits, they’re rubbish.
My clients get the diagnostic version of GEO, which starts from what AI answers say about their business now. Belmore Digital’s own site is checked against the same audit I run for clients.
Across the AI platforms, we now feature in more AI citations and references, meaning answers that name us as a source.
What changes how AI answers describe a business

AI answers change how they describe a business when what the rest of the web says about it changes. The rest of the web means its reviews and the mentions it gets on other sites, linked or not, and they count once AI systems can read the business’s own site.
Work aimed at that, for that particular business, is what moves the needle.
Your own website and its schema (the code that spells out your business details for machines) make the claim about who you are. Reviews and other sites decide whether it holds up.
When the two conflict, I’ve seen AI answers side with the reputation a business earns on other sites, and shift only as fast as new reviews arrive and get picked up.
How long a GEO result takes comes down to how much needs fixing in your business.
Other sites decide what the answer says. Google’s index decides whether your pages can be used at all.
Google’s AI Overviews and AI Mode link only to pages Google has indexed and could show in Search with a snippet (the short extract under a result). The site must also be included in those features in Search Console, and how AI Overviews draw on Google’s index has the detail.
- Put the way your website describes what you do next to what your reviews and the sites that mention you say, and note where they differ.
- Count how much of your current GEO plan happens on sites other than yours.
How to recognise templated GEO work

Templated GEO work starts with a tool and a domain name, and gives every client the same recommendations with the names swapped. You can recognise it by its first deliverable.
The offerings I see promise an entity targeting document first. Entity targeting is the research that sets which topics and services AI answers should connect a business with, and here a tool produces it from the domain name. By design, a client in another industry gets the same document with different nouns.
The audit that follows runs in under an hour.
Its recommendations differ for each client the way a horoscope differs for each sign.
The copy gets a sprinkling of the topic terms the tool picked out. Schema gets filled to the minimum fields, well short of what schema can say about a business.
Citations get built on whatever directories take submissions at scale, though in my experience one mention on a site relevant to your field tends to do more than a directory listing.
None of it needs anyone to know the business. It scales beautifully (for the seller).
Run a business through a template and it comes out looking like a thousand others of its type, which leaves AI answers nothing to tell it apart by.
- Read your current GEO report with your business name blacked out, and ask whether it could be about anyone in your industry.
- Check whether its citation work is a list of directory sign-ups, and which of those sites your customers would ever read.
Why diagnosing AI visibility needs someone who knows your business

Diagnosing AI visibility is a judgement about which problems cost the business customers, and that takes someone who knows the business. An automated tool knows the domain name.
The diagnosis compares what AI answers say about the business now with what they should say. I check how ChatGPT and the others describe a client as part of entity targeting, because their answers show whether the targeting is right.
What I find is that AI answers usually get a business’s core topics right. How strongly the business turns up for them is what varies, and after that come the secondary and related topics, which the entity targeting work maps out.
Then comes the judgement.
Say an audit turns up 15 fixable issues. Three of them matter commercially, and the other 12 are real but can wait.
A tool sorts all 15 by a generic score. I tell the client which three to fix first, and why.
I make that call in a GEO audit. Mine run one to three weeks, set by access and client feedback, against the hour a tool takes.
- Ask whether the diagnosis includes entity targeting for your business, and which services it puts first.
- Judge a diagnosis by whether it tells you which few findings to fix first, and why those.
How to order AI search fixes so your team can deliver them

Order AI search fixes by their impact, by what depends on what, by who has to do the work and by how long each takes to show, all for your business in particular. When I set priorities for a client, those four decide it.
Of the four, dependency never changes. Crawlability comes first: AI crawlers (the bots that fetch pages for AI systems) must be able to get in and read the site, because schema they can’t reach does nothing. The order GEO work runs in sets out the rest.
The other three change with the business.
Say the highest-impact fix on the list is a site-wide change to the page layout, putting proper headings and schema across the service pages. It needs a developer, and the developer is unavailable for two months.
The work that needs no developer, such as rewriting the key pages and asking customers for reviews, starts this week.
A template has no idea the developer is away.
- List who will do each fix, and when they’re free, before you agree the order.
- Ask whoever set the order which fixes are waiting on another, and why.
- Every quarter, check what has been fixed against the priorities your GEO audit set, and whether the order still suits your team.
Six questions to ask a GEO agency before you hire one

Good answers to these six questions talk about your situation, and four of them name your business, so ask them before you hire a GEO agency.
1. What do AI answers say about my business now, and how did you find out? A good answer quotes what ChatGPT and the others say about you today, and says where they looked.
2. Can I see a sample report, with the client’s details removed? If the sample and your proposed plan read alike with the nouns changed, both came from a template.
3. Why is your first recommendation first, for my business? A good answer names the fix, who will do it and what it’s worth to you.
4. How will you check the right AI crawlers can get into my site and read it? A good answer separates the bots that fetch pages for answers from the bots that collect training data, as OpenAI’s crawler page does with OAI-SearchBot (for ChatGPT’s search answers) and GPTBot (for training). It also covers a crawler that gets in but can’t read the page, including pages whose content only appears once JavaScript runs. A site an AI crawler can’t read is worth nothing to that system, and what blocks AI crawlers goes further.
5. What will you do about what other sites say about me? A good answer covers your reviews, mentions and citations on other sites, which in my experience is where the description tends to come from.
6. What do you guarantee? A good answer describes the work and the order it runs in, and promises no outcome. Nobody can guarantee one, because the businesses an AI answer names today can be replaced by others.
If the answers are vague, the work will be too.
They’re the questions I expect to be asked myself. For two to three years, my GEO engagements have answered them by finding out what AI answers say about a business now, fixing what matters first and earning what other sites say about it. If you’re still deciding whether to hire anyone at all, who should do your GEO weighs it up.
FAQ

Why doesn’t automated advice for AI answers get results? Automated advice for AI answers gives every business the same recommendations, because a tool has no way of knowing what AI answers say about yours or which problems cost you customers. It starts from a domain name and stops there. What gets results is a diagnosis by someone who knows the business, beginning with how AI answers describe it now.
How do I know if a GEO agency is doing the work properly? Ask what AI answers say about your business now and how they found out, and ask for a sample report with the client’s details removed, to compare with the plan they propose for you. If the two read alike with the nouns changed, both came from a template. Ask why their first recommendation comes first for you, and how they’ll check AI crawlers can get into your site and read it. Then ask what they’ll do about what other sites say about you, and what they guarantee. Expect the answers about your situation to name your business.
What does a good programme for AI answers involve? Good Generative Engine Optimisation (GEO) starts with a diagnosis of what AI answers say about the business now. The fixes go in an order the business can deliver, crawlability first, with pages and schema that say what this business does and for whom. The work also reaches reviews, mentions and citations on other sites. What GEO takes, part by part sets out the parts and their order. Automated advice skips the diagnosis and starts with a list of fixes.
Can anyone guarantee a business will appear in AI answers? No. There are no outcome guarantees in GEO, and the businesses an AI answer names today can be replaced by others. What a provider can promise is the work, starting with a diagnosis of the business and then the fixes, done in the right order. An agency promising a placement is promising something it doesn’t control.
TL;DR
- Templated GEO advice gives every business the same recommendations. Like automated SEO audits, it’s rubbish.
- AI answers change how they describe a business when what other sites say about it changes.
- Templated work gives itself away in its first deliverable, and its recommendations differ the way horoscopes do. Your stars may vary.
- A diagnosis needs someone who knows the business. A tool has the domain name.
- Order fixes by impact, dependency, who does the work and how long it takes to show, with crawlability first.
- Ask an agency six questions and expect the answers about your situation to name your business. Nobody can guarantee the outcome.
If you’d like your GEO built on a diagnosis of your business, talk to JB.
